|
|
#51 |
|
Member [45%]
|
Sarcasm is very hard to read online and most INTJ have a sarcastic streak in them. This is either the most funniest topic on the boards or the most offensive.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#52 | ||||||||||||||||||
|
Core Member [155%]
|
I'm defining it as length of time and how many different peoples have persecuted them.
Err...
A lovely, if vague term.
"We were kind enough to not let these people get systematically murdered and their entire livelihoods destroyed. It's their fault!" |
||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#53 |
|
Member [02%]
|
I was born a jew, but don't consider myself as one, I'm agnostic. All religions have only one purpose, to have control over the masses (that's the only useful thing that we learnt from Marx). However, that is only one aspect. If you attack jewish dogmas, go ahead and attack the christian ones, muslims ones, buddhists ones and every other religion dogma in the world. Assuming that you are a rational being, if you are not judging every religion as it should, you are being inconsistent with rationality itself and shame on you. Assuming you belong to any faith, thus being an irrational being, you are just being xenophobic if you attack any other religion.
Anyways, many of you fail to notice one little detail about this particular situation, some of you (and plenty around the world) blame it all on the jews (orthodox, reformist, hassidic, ashkenazi, sephardi, ethnically born but agnostic, etc...). It's not the talmud with its anti-goyim outdated rules and it's not that because some jews earned fortunes with effort and a lot of hard work through many generations (social determinism) that people hate jews now a days, it's because of the zionists. Being jewish doesn't imply being a zionist, take note of that. They are a political party and as such, they DO have an agenda (probably has something to do with control). Come on, having a jewish country?!?! WHAT THE FUCK!!! Having an muslim country??!?! WHAT THE FUCK AGAIN!!!! Having a catholic country (vatican)?!?! WHAT THE FUCKING FUCK!!!! These are cradles of xenophobia, ignorance and irrationality; and it's way worst when you mix in politics and religion. Now, you may be wondering about "the human need to believe argument" and why am I dissing on all religions, here is my answer: it is actually, the human need to being manipulated, leaded, to be tranquilized about the unknown through a fairy tale. You may say I'm xenophobic or racist, not really, I'm just someone who likes to rationalize everything and doesn't believe in exogenous dogmas as a rational way of existing. Some illustrative examples: You don't choose these initially, you are born within their dogmas; however, you can opt out of them: -Christians = Religion -Muslims = Religion -Jewish = Religion -etc... When you mix politics with religion, you get these entities: -Hamas = Left wing political party with xenophobic tendencies. -Zionism = Right wing political party with xenophobic tendencies. -Vatican = Hegemonic political party in the middle ages with xenophobic tendencies, now just a proselitist political party. -etc... When you mix politics with nationalism, you get these entities: Nazism = Extreme right wing political party with xenophobic tendencies. Communism = Extreme left wing political party with xenophobic tendencies. tl; dr: You cannot criticize someone for being something he or she has no choice over it (being born within certain religion or ethnicity for instance); however, you can and should criticize ideas (such as religions or political movements) and conscious decisions.
Last edited by zmo; 06-09-2011 at 05:56 AM.
|
|
|
|
|
|
#54 | ||||||
|
Core Member [227%]
|
That is debatable. I know plenty of people who think the Chairman of the Fed is grossly incompetent.
Most powerful Jews do not privately identify themselves as white, in public it is often a different story depending on the audience they are speaking with. They identify themselves as Jews. Most white people don't know this and even if they did they still wouldn't understand the full extent of what it means because the public is ignorant about such distinctions. |
||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#55 | |||
|
Core Member [309%]
|
As far as I can tell, jews have managed to not be well looked upon (as a group) through much of history. Jews also make a bigger deal of the fact that they've been persecuted, something that most other groups don't do. |
|||
|
|
|
|
|
#56 | ||||||
|
Member [12%]
MBTI: xNxP
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 516
|
Jewish culture teaches that debt is slavery and being a lendor is a blessing. It values financial stewardship and circulating money within the Jewish community for self-preservation and prosperous living. Being honest but shrewd in business is a virtue. If you see an opportunity, jump on it. Opportunismm may have been frowned upon. I really don't care. That doesn't make it wrong. If something terrible happens that you cause and you profit from it, that is wrong. If something terrible happens and you find a new market niche for it, good for you. You say yourself they haggled useless goods. It is not as if you are arguing they price gouged essential goods and strangled the market during hard times. No. They haggled. How does that hurt anyone?
Any real arguments behind this? BTW, you weren't bamboozled into a holy war. You started one up again when you supported creating a Hebrew state on one of the most contested, if not the most fought over, plots of land in history. |
||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#57 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
You really have no clue, do you?
Says all about you.
.....you really have no clue. The Russian mafia have always been a jewish mafia. Fact.
Well, it doesn't prove I'm wrong, thats for sure.
Goldman Sachs? Thank god for them. (Using your kind of arguments)
I agree on this, believe it or not. Doesn't take away that the secular jews are the ones that people tend to dislike.
This is true, not much else to say.
Also true.
You've pretty much proven me right by writing this. Thank you.
Well, they had no choice but to value literacy. I'm not contending you there.
This was a long time ago. Jews aren't disliked because of their religion, but their actions.
I haven't made any comments like that.
Just an observation of reality.
Loosing the war caused alot of hardship for the germans. It did not cause the anti-semitism. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#58 | |||
|
Member [12%]
MBTI: xNxP
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 516
|
1.) So the Jews are immoral for knowing how to work well within Capitalism? If the Jews adapted quicker to capitalism than other groups it is because principles of capitalism are part of the culture. Traditionally, Jews respect ambition, as well. This is true of many cultures. You can call this greed if you want to. |
|||
|
|
|
|
|
#59 |
|
Member [45%]
|
Jews aren't the only persecuted people. As a matter of fact they pretty well for themselves all things considered. That's gotta piss off some people. Then the Jews have to complain and whine about everything. That's gotta piss them off even more. Man how dare they have the nerve to over come past hardships. Those Jews are like totally taking over. The other day at the market I saw Mini-Bagel Pizza bites. That was part of the back room deal between the Jew who secretly financed World War 2 with both sides. If the Allied won. The Jews would get total control of Italy. Now their corrupting our youth with they mini-bagel pizza bites.
|
|
|
|
|
|
#60 | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
Core Member [155%]
|
Oh, you mean MARX? The Jewish guy who philosophized up communism? And whose ideas were totally misconstrued and abused to effectively establish dictatorship instead of what he outlined as communism?
Way to go for the ad hom! Hurraaaa!!!
If you have this "fact," then please cite it.
That's what happens when your argument is
So I should dislike all Germans because of Hitler and the Holocaust? I should dislike all Palestinians because of the ongoing conflict? I should should dislike Russians because of the cold war?
Thanks god I have your earlier post to recognize your sarcasm. >.>
Last edited by Vagrant; 06-09-2011 at 11:11 PM.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#61 | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
More like these guys:
I'm not totally ignorant, please read again.
Not just any guy. The guy. Also quite hard to find hard evidence about criminal elements in rotten societies. Russian mafia has had a disproportionate number of jewish leaders (not only in the sense of being the highest leader) just as with communism.
Probably good people. I don't contest you with that. I don't mean to attack all jews, I just believe theres something seriously rotten with their culture which only focus is themselves. Divide and conquer. Always an agenda.
Alot of media I see(joke aside).
1.Germans
Well, Israel is pretty much a window to how the average jew thinks, its a democracy.
Last edited by Luthor; 06-10-2011 at 07:12 AM.
Reason: Changing from code to link
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#62 | ||||||||||||||||||
|
Core Member [155%]
|
Control + F + "Jew" = 1 Result
Oh? Do explain?
You missed the point entirely. I do not judge people based on their birth or origin. I judge them based on how they treat me. And yes, I have German, Palestinian, and Russian friends. They also recognize me as an individual.
Are you daft? Germany was a democracy until Hitler. He got voted in, but not by a simple majority. That doesn't represent the average German's thinking at the time.
When all else fails, resort to the ad hominem! |
||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#63 | |||
|
Member [12%]
MBTI: xNxP
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 516
|
So I should hate Germans, but then they are justified in hating me back. Blacks should hate whites for the oppression, but of course that would mean whites are justified in hating back. Japanese should hate Americans, but then that would mean... etc. etc. etc. |
|||
|
|
|
|
|
#64 | |||
|
Member [17%]
|
Reading the diverse range of high quality opinion and literature that comes out of Israel would suggest otherwise. Leaving aside the millions of Jewish people who live outside of Israel and don't participate in its democracy. |
|||
|
|
|
|
|
#65 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
Trying not to offend you, but did you read the names and bio of the communist leaders? Or did that just slip by?
The link wasn't meant to be related to that comment. That comment was about my sarcastic remark of Goldman Sachs. I'm fully aware of that people of jewish decent have started alot of successful companies.
So, since when is wikipedia a source of the truth and the whole truth? In the afghan culture page, does it say that pedofilia is a part of their culture?
This isn't the first time youre on the defence is it? You sure know alot about argument techniques. Are you sure youre just not another rampant JDL:er.
I recognize you as an individual too. You just seem to be one of those that have to defend or marginalize whatever critique or observation that has been made about Israel/jewish culture. The holocaust was probably the worst thing to ever have happened in Europe, but you don't see any german worthwhile denying it or marginalizing it. Whats happening in Gaza is comparable to Warsaw. But the terrorist palestinians should blame themselves, right? Shame on them for being oppressed.
True, they didn't know what monster he was. Israelis do know what kind of person Lieberman is. Still he is your deputy prime minister.
I do believe that a majority of jews are zionists. "Many" is a subjective word, something youre accusing me for being, and I am in a way. At least I'm not denying it. You can always find a rationality behind everything.
After looking at wikipedia what that terribly difficult word meant, I couldn't agree more:
Of course its better if people could get along on equal terms. But some just don't see it that way.
Any jew can almost immediately become an Israeli citizen (don't recognize this in any other christian western country). And allot of jews that don't live in Israel are Israeli citizens. And concerning the opinions and literature, how come they always seem to elect warmongers and likes?
Last edited by Vagrant; 06-11-2011 at 01:26 AM.
Reason: Broken quote tag
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#66 | ||||||
|
Member [12%]
MBTI: xNxP
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 516
|
Hitler was elected after staging a military coupe and one of his primary platforms was his hatred of Jews. Would most Germans have supported the extent to which Hitler persecuted Jews? No, of course not. Did they enable it and openly support lesser levels of perescution, including eviction from homes/businesses?
Apparently you don't see it that way either if you think it is justified to hate modern Germans for WWII. |
||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#67 | |||||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
First of all, thank you for asking questions in a civil manner. I like when people try to prove me wrong or at least that my trail of thought is wrong and I'm open for changing my mind. Discussing without being on a rampage at least makes me listen.
Yes, he didn't try to hide that he was an anti-semite. Alot of Germans were probably anti-semites too and supported some levels of persecution.
I was mostly just upset of your unwillingness to understand that the ability to be a successful capitalist/opportunist (capitalism is good, however it should be coupled with a social responsibility and morals) isn't always a positive trait. Well, you didn't exactly crush my prejudices about jews there, rather you cemented it.
Well, thats wrong, just look how it was there before 1948. There might have been some kind of tensions, but nothing thats comparable to what is happening today. The difference is that the jews are the occupiers and the Palestinians are robbed of their lands. So in a way the jews that are defending it are way worse than the palestinians that defend what was once theirs. |
|||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#68 | |||
|
Veteran Member [85%]
|
You're kidding, right? |
|||
|
|
|
|
|
#69 | |||
|
Veteran Member [60%]
|
How ethnocentric can most of them be with a Jewish-Gentile intermarriage rate of 52% in America? |
|||
|
|
|
|
|
#70 | ||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
Seriously, after all I've written you choose to comment this.
Compared to others they do seem ethnocentric, they always point out that they are jewish (in a ethnic sense(see quote above yours)), right?
Last edited by Luthor; 06-10-2011 at 05:07 PM.
Reason: Adding quote, spelling
|
||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#71 | |||||||||
|
Veteran Member [85%]
|
In other words: you believe whichever study confirms your prejudices. My "ego" is offended whenever I read blatant bullshit about many things, those completely unrelated to Jews as well.
If there isn't, then how do you explain the significant overrepresentation of Jews at all levels of American academia? IQ has something to do with that, no?
Your point is...? |
|||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#72 | ||||||||||||||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
From wikipedia:
"some studies in the 70s", yeah that seems carved in stone.
If I used someone like Lynn as a source, I would have gotten shit for it, but you can?
Its a part of your culture?
IQ probably isn't as effected by genetics as you might think. Also that you "real"(ashkenazi is thought to be of 35-55% european decent, perhaps thats where you got your IQ from) jews doesn't seem to appreciate your black brothers that much.
I bet its higher than yours, for sure.
Last edited by Luthor; 06-10-2011 at 06:13 PM.
Reason: Clarification
|
||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#73 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Core Member [155%]
|
Uhh no?
Ignoring the grammar glitches here, I'm pointing out how fallacious your arguments are. And no, I don't belong to the JDL, or any other Jewish association for that matter.
Uhhh... because these critiques are fallacious. Jewish culture is not the same as Israeli culture. Israeli culture is not unified. Jewish culture is not unified. You seem to assume that they're all similar. It's like saying American culture is all cowboys shooting guns and going out and killing people. That's a minor fraction of American culture.
Again, the issue is more complex than that, and is rooted in history as well.
My "prime minister" is Obama. I live in America.
And I've already told you my motives. And my background. Do you really want me to start handing out my personal information now?
Really? Do you need me to say anything else? |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#74 | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
New Member [01%]
|
And you are calling me daft? 7 out of 7 leaders in that revolution were jewish. And yes the Weimar Republic was pretty bad, but at least it wasn't communist. Why did you leave out these, this was how the general european communist party looked like. Grossly overrepresented by jews:
Where does it disprove my point, you're using glorifying wiki-articles about the torah secular jewish culture etc. Wheres is everything in those articles that says that jews should marry their nieces, ok to rob goys of their possessions etc.
Then you're just ignorant.
Well, again you are marginalizing. You can't compare Israel and America. America is by no means the perfect country, but ages ahead of Israel. America doesn't cage half a million people and use excessive violence against them.
Please tell me then. And don't dig up that book of yours that states that Israel only belongs to the chosen people.
No, please don't. Just don't leave out information that is right under your nose. Thats worse than not finding explicit sources for everything. You're purposely manipulating. |
|||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#75 |
|
Core Member [162%]
MBTI: INTP
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 6,508
|
I kinda like Jews but I wish they would quit with all the "oppressed throughout history" line. Like the Jews were some kind of saints that never did anything to deserve it. I have read comments of the time and they were regarded as rascals. We have all met those shady characters, with uncertain income sources, who always seem to have some scheme on the go. Hardly surprising the good citizens of the county got upset about them and decided to kick them out.
Shylock reflects the image as seen by the gentiles of the time. If you read the Magna Carta you will find Jews are specifically referenced and not favourably. The question is: Did the Jews deserve it? |
|
|
|
![]() |
| Tags |
| judaism |
| Thread Tools | |
|
|